He had "borrowed" a couch pillow for his second pillow. An old, feather-filled, somewhat pokey, not-machine-washable couch pillow.
I decided to get rid of all those pillows when we got rid of the couches they matched. Freecycle girl took some, the rest went on top of the trash can and someone took them.
I finally made a cover for the new borrowed couch pillow last weekend.
See that fabric? Yeah, he likes it. Even if he won't show his face ;)